I receently, like almost everyone one else with the slightest bit of openmindednes, be it only a crack, went to see Brokeback Mountain. It seems as though I was the only one of these millons of people who didn't think it was bee's kneees. Now, I have to say, it's not entirly the movie's fault. It was overhyped, which pushed my expectations to a point that the movie was unable to fulfill simply due to the intrinsic nature of the short story it was based on. Maybe I shouldn't have read the story before I saw the movie, but after seeing all the raving previews about how this was a "sweeping love story", and "wonderfully romantic" and to give the movie a slogan like "Love is a force of nature", you better deliver. Anyway, I wanted to see what lay at the heart of this movie. So I read the short story by Ann Preloux(sp?). She did a buetiful job in capurting the West, the attitudes, the people , the life. But she certainly didn't write a "sweeping, romantic, love story." And from what i got from the story, she didn't intend to. Because of the setting and the characters, it would have been inpossible to write it what way and still keep it at all realistic. This story is actually included in a anthology of other stories about the West. It was not included in an anthology of short, gay love stories, which should tell you something right there. Then again, most people I talk to didn't even know this was based on a short story. I almost think you have to be from the west to truely understand this story, you have to have known people like Ennis and Jack. And cowboys from texas and farmboys from Indiana or the south don't count. You have to have known true cowboys from the west, to understand what kind of a world they grew up in, to have grown up in that world yourself. Like in the move, when they had to say goodbye at the end of the summer and they wound up in a fight and Ennis punched Jack, that made perfect sense to me. But there were a lot of gasps in the theater. I understood that these characters would be unable to have a romantic goodbye with a kiss. They weren't capable of that kind of expression, especially Ennis. So he did what he knew how to do when he was confused, he fought. Another reaction I found funny was from the friend that I went to see the movie with the couldn't understand why they just rushed into sex. I had to explain that cowboys weren't really into forplay and their forplay had been eating togaether and talking a little and drinking together. Hell, that's actually a lot of forplay for cowboys. And a lot of people were confused as to why they married women and had children. That should make perfect sense to southerners, land of the Married Gay Man. One thing that bothered me about both the story and the movie was Ennis's character. I saw nothing in him that was loveable, let alone anough to make 2 people fall in love with him and for Jack to put up with for 20 years. Maybe he extremly good in bed. I see no other explination. So, in conclusion, I am coming out of my own little closet in a way. I feel like that little old lady in In and Out (a horrible movie, by the way) when she said pretty much the only funny line in the whole thing, "I'm going to say it right out loud where everyone can hear it, I hated the Bridges of Madison County". Well, I'm going to say it out loud too, I Didn't Like Brokeback Mountain. So there.
Posted by phoenixrising76
at 6:57 AM CST
Updated: Wednesday, 8 March 2006 5:45 PM CST